Johns vs Thurston

Bit of a debate going around the media at the moment, surprised no one has started this thread yet. Always going to come down personal opinion and state allegiances, who do you think is the better halfback

NRL
Johns:
249 games, 164 wins, %65.60 win rate
82 tries, 917 goals, 22 field goals, 2190 points
2 premierships
1 Clive Churchill medal
3 Dally M medals
2 golden boots

Thurston:
250 games, 135 wins, % 57.2 win rate
81 tries, 653 goals, 10 field goals 1640
1 premiership (off the bench)
3 Dally M medals
2 golden boots

State of origin
Johns:
23 games, 13 wins, % 56.52 win rate
4 tries, 37 goals, 4 field goals, 94 points
5 series wins
2 clean sweeps
4 man of the match awards

Thurston
30 games, 19 wins, %63.33 win rate
5 tries, 76 goals, 2 field goals, 174 points
8 series wins
1 clean sweep
4 man of the match awards

Australia
Johns:
23 games, 20 wins, %86.96
9 tries, 66 goals, 168 points
2 world cups

Thurston
31 games, 29 wins, % 93.55
12 tries, 140 goals, 328 points
1 world cup

*all stats from http://ift.tt/1kD68Lo

Johns vs Thurston